To achieve the grade 12, students
should meet the following learning objectives with no or only minor
mistakes or errors: After having followed the course, the students
are expected to be able to:
- Explain the content of Weber’s, Foucault’s, Luhmann’s and
Habermas’s theories about leadership, power and communication.
- Analyze the main topics and concepts of the course, which are
leadership, power, communication, politics, bureaucracy, risk
management, self-government, systemic communication, normative
communication, management communication.
- Reach their own conclusions on the main topics and concepts of
the course, which are leadership, power, communication, politics,
bureaucracy, risk management, self-government, systemic
communication, normative communication, management
communication.
|
The aim of this course is to introduce participants to theories
of leadership in contemporary organizations by using the
fundamental concepts and frameworks of four major thinkers, Max
Weber, Michel Foucault, Niklas Luhmann and Jürgen Habermas. The
course is primarily a theoretical course. The purpose of such
an introduction is to facilitate participants’
theoretical understanding of how leadership operates in
contemporary societies.
Topics of the course:
The course has the following 6 topics:
Topic 1: General introduction to leadership in the European
tradition
Leadership has been discussed in European culture since ancient
Greek democracy. Thus, the course begins with a short overview of
different understandings of leadership in the European history of
ideas. This will enable participants to situate the thought of
Weber, Foucault, Luhmann and Habermas.
Topic 2: Weber’s theory of leadership and
bureaucracy
Weber founded the basic theory of modern legal and rational
bureaucracy, which remains the standard for all other theories of
public administration. Participants will engage with Weber’s idea
of different forms of leadership (Herrschaft) in
traditional, charismatic and legal-rational forms of organization.
The legal-rational model will be presented in detail. Key relevant
themes include Weber’s concepts of leadership as vocation
(Beruf), the ethos of office and ethic of responsibility,
and the danger of blind obedience.
Topic 3: Foucault’s theory of governance, risk-management
and self-government
Foucault is famous for his central concern with the way we conduct
ourselves and others in relation to truth and knowledge. To
lead in his terms is to conduct others and oneself, or what he
terms government. Participants will become acquainted with
his analytics of government, and its key terms such as political
rationality, governmentality, technologies of the self and
technologies of governing. They will examine his relationship to
Weber’s account of rationalization and bureaucracy and how his
approach can be used to study the ethos of office and professional
transformation within contemporary management and audit and risk
cultures, and the way contemporary organizational practices rely on
forms of self-government.
Topic 4: Luhmann’s theory of leadership as decision making
and risk management in contingent organizational
communication
Luhmann has developed a radical theory of communication in which
organizations are viewed as contingent autonomous self-reproductive
or ‘autopoietic’ systems of communication. Such a communication is
always threatened by the possibility of a total collapse. In this
perspective, leadership becomes a form of risk management of
communication. In principle, communication can only be momentary
stabilized by decisions that again have to be stabilized by new
confirmations. In Luhmann’s theory, the usual relation between
agency and communication is turned around so that agency is totally
subordinated to communication. Leadership has become a perpetual
making of risky decisions, which only can be momentarily stabilized
in the statement of something as simple as the purpose, direction
and aim of the organization. In Luhmann’s perspective of
leadership, there is no place for a normative evaluation of such a
statement.
Topic 5: Habermas’s theory of leadership as a normative
loaded communication versus systemic management communication in
organizations
Habermas has developed a theory of communicative action in which
communicative leadership has to be understood as a reflexive
communication with all implicated parties. Habermas’s theory can be
seen as a critique of Weber at the same time as it opens a utopian
horizon for more democratic forms of administration. Habermas also
includes Luhmann’s perspective in his theory of communicative
leadership. For Habermas, social systems are acceptable as
autopoietic communication as long as such systemic management
communication does not substitute a normative communication, when
it is needed. In this case, communication has to be a form of
personal ethical reflection and normative communication. The leader
has to be able to take a personal responsibility.
Topic 6: Leadership as a concluding combination of
different organizational perspectives
The course will conclude with a discussion of the leadership
theories of Weber, Foucault, Luhmann and Habermas in relation to
each other. The aim of the course is to give the participants the
ability to combine the four theories in different
perspectives.
|